top of page

Contact Us Today!

My Company Owes More Than It Owns – Is It Insolvent?

Writer: Solvendi - A Tradition of Excellence
Solvendi - A Tradition of Excellence
2 days ago
6 min read

If your company owes more than the value of everything it owns, you may assume that it is insolvent and should be liquidated. That is an important warning sign, but it does not tell you the whole story.

When assessing a struggling business, the more useful questions are: What is the company turning over each month? What does it cost to operate? Is it making a genuine profit? And can the underlying business still be made financially sustainable?

A company may own valuable assets and still be unable to pay its monthly expenses. A service business may own very few assets but remain profitable. The real question is whether there is still a viable business underneath the debt.


Business owner reviewing company finances to determine whether the business is insolvent
Assets and liabilities are important, but they do not tell you whether the underlying business is still financially viable.

Is the Company Making Money or Just Generating Turnover?

Turnover and profit are not the same thing. A company can generate significant monthly sales while still losing money because the cost of producing those sales, staff, premises, suppliers and other operating expenses consume more than the business earns.

Start with the basics: Monthly turnover – cost of sales – operating expenses = what is actually left?

If very little remains, or the company consistently operates at a loss, ask whether that position can realistically be changed.


Can the Company's Expenses Be Reduced?

Some expenses may have been necessary when the company was established but no longer make commercial sense.

Staffing is a good example. Positions that were essential years ago may no longer be necessary because production methods, processes or customer requirements have changed. Long-serving employees may also have received salary increases over many years, leaving the company with staffing costs its current turnover and profit margins can no longer support.

This does not mean employees can simply be dismissed. Restructuring and retrenchment have legal and financial consequences. But the true cost of the staffing structure cannot be ignored when assessing whether the business remains viable. The same review should apply to premises, equipment, subscriptions, professional services and other recurring expenses.


Will More Marketing Actually Solve the Problem?

When turnover falls, the immediate response is often: we need more business. But more turnover does not necessarily mean more profit. Before spending additional money on marketing, establish whether the additional business is likely to generate a sufficient profit margin.

If every new sale requires more stock, staff, production costs or borrowing, increasing turnover may actually worsen cash flow. Marketing should generate profitable business, not simply more activity.


Are Your Suppliers Still Competitive?

Long-standing supplier relationships can be valuable, but loyalty should not prevent a business from reviewing its costs. Prices, payment terms and alternatives change. If another suitable supplier can provide the same quality product or service at a materially better price or on better terms, the effect on the company's profit margin may be significant.

Ask a simple question:

Are you still paying for the company you used to operate rather than the company you operate today?


Business owners reviewing company expenses, financial reports and profitability
Turnover alone does not make a business profitable. Costs, margins and operating expenses need to be examined together.

Poor Accounting Can Hide a Serious Problem

One of the most concerning things a struggling company can do is stop spending money on proper accounting. Unfortunately, accounting is often one of the first expenses cut when cash flow becomes tight. Without reliable accounting records, directors may start judging the health of the company by the balance in its bank account rather than its actual financial position.

Proper accounting should tell you what the company earns, spends, owes, is owed and must pay in tax. Most importantly, it should tell you whether the business is actually profitable. Without this information, directors can continue trading without understanding how serious the financial position has become.


If the Company Cannot Pay SARS, Pay Attention

For us, a company's inability to keep its tax obligations current is one of the clearest warnings that there may already be a serious financial problem. If the company is paying salaries, suppliers and operating expenses while repeatedly falling behind with SARS, the business may appear to be surviving while a substantial liability accumulates in the background.

This is particularly concerning where VAT has been collected from customers or PAYE deducted from employees, but the company does not have the money available to pay SARS. Tax arrears should therefore not be viewed simply as another account that can wait until business improves.


CIPC and Company Compliance Still Matter

Financial difficulty can also lead directors to stop attending to basic company compliance. Annual returns, beneficial ownership declarations and other CIPC requirements still need to be dealt with. Continued non-compliance can ultimately result in the company being deregistered. This is more serious than an outstanding administrative requirement.

Once a company has been deregistered and removed from the companies register, it is dissolved. It cannot simply continue operating as though nothing has happened. In practice, however, some companies continue trading after deregistration.


A director may continue to:

  • issue invoices and receive company payments;

  • order goods from suppliers;

  • sign contracts or lease agreements;

  • employ and pay staff;

  • collect VAT from customers; or

  • incur further debt in the company's name.


Sometimes the director simply does not realise that the company has been deregistered. That itself demonstrates why proper accounting and company administration matter. The position is more serious where a director knows that the company has been deregistered but continues conducting business and incurring liabilities regardless. The director's conduct and potential personal exposure may then need to be considered.

If a deregistered company is still operating, the position should be addressed rather than ignored. Depending on the circumstances, this may involve reinstating the company and bringing its statutory affairs up to date, or considering whether its financial position means liquidation is now the more appropriate course.


Business financial reports being reviewed to understand a company’s financial position

So, Is the Company Insolvent?

If the company owes more than it owns, that is an important warning sign. But don't look at the balance sheet in isolation. Ask whether the business itself still works.

Can unnecessary expenses be reduced? Can margins improve? Are staffing costs appropriate? Are suppliers competitive? Would additional marketing produce profitable business? Are the accounting records reliable? Can SARS and current operating obligations actually be paid? If sensible changes can return the company to sustainable profitability, there may still be a viable business worth saving.

But if the company survives only because it delays suppliers, does not pay SARS, borrows more money, relies on directors taking personal loans or continually accumulates new debt, the problem may no longer be temporary. At that point, continuing to trade may simply create a larger problem.


When Should Liquidation Be Considered when a company owes more than it owns?

Liquidation should be considered when there is no realistic way to return the company to a sustainable position and continuing to operate will result in further liabilities accumulating. The earlier the financial position is assessed, the more opportunity there is to determine whether the business can still be saved or whether continuing to trade is making matters worse. An insolvency assessment should therefore do more than compare assets and liabilities.

It should answer one fundamental question: Is there still a commercially viable business that can realistically recover?

If there isn't, delaying liquidation may only increase the company's debt and the risks facing its directors.


Contact Solvendi for a confidential assessment of your company's financial position. We can assess the company's turnover, expenses, liabilities, assets, SARS position and other relevant circumstances to determine whether the business can realistically be restructured or whether liquidation should be considered.


Disclaimer: This article is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be regarded as legal advice. Director liability depends on the particular circumstances, transactions and agreements involved. Professional advice should be obtained regarding your individual circumstances.

 

Solvendi Divider

Contact us to discuss your current situation and receive a free detailed assessment of how the process works and what your costs will be. We have legal experts with 20 years experience that can guide you through the process. Our main aim is to be as informative as possible. Let's Chat.


Solvendi Company Liquidations and Consumer Sequestrations

Solvendi Company Liquidations and Consumer Sequestrations

If you require advice with regards to Sequestration, Business Liquidations, Insolvency, Bankruptcy or Credit Rehabilitation kindly contact SOLVENDI as follows:

National: 087 220 0710

Head Office: 010 880 7589


Solvendi Company Liquidations and Consumer Sequestrations


Comments


Talk to Us

bottom of page